To Actias members with Papilio species

    Hello Actias Members,

    Back in November, I had 2 Papilio species. Graphium agamemnon and Papilio Troilus.

    Unfortunately, both only lived about 2 days. I noticed the night of the day they hatched, around 9 pm they would start to become very active. They would become very clumsy and unable to fly. 9 pm is an unusual time for this species to be active.

    It made me sad because there was nothing I could do.

    This has also happened to P. glaucus and any other swallowtails.

    I really need answers. I have some Papilio maackii right now. They just hatched. I cannot afford for this to happen again.

    So far they seem ok.

    The humidity is high and the temperature is around 65-68 at night.

    Has this happened to anyone?

    Best Regards,

    Ethan

    :hilfe:

  • ANZEIGE

    Hmm ... have not idea whats wrong.

    I never had Papilio troilus or Graphium agamemnon, but I had Papilio glaucus, multicaudatus , eurymedon for several years. Absolutly no problem to keep them 2-3 weeks alive. I do not care about humidity - probably on lower range because they were inside. I am avoiding direct sunlight, for female stimulation during ovipositing I am using artificial lights. As for temperature it is 20-26C during day and little lower during night ( open windows ).

    Crucial part is feeding. Papilionidae have large body and they need rich food source. Self feeding is not good idea if it is not large greenhouse with abundant flowers. I prefer manual feeding. I am skipping first day after emerging. Then I am feeding daily, during hot days even twice. Be careful with feeding dilution and I prefer to keep it inside fridge to avoid bacterial disease and just before feeding to bring it to room to reach room temperature. After few days I make new dilution.

    Anyway 2 days .... it should live longer even without food. Have you any substance in room which can be toxic for insects ? Electronic repelents for moskytos or something similar ?

    Also sometimes when stock is inbreeded, specimens are crippled. It must not be visible on first sight ( wings deformations ), but it can be also thorax problems which leads to early death. To place out this possibility is to look if imago feeds properly.

    Thanks so much for your answer.

    I don’t think there is anything toxic in the room.

    I also have Antherina suraka and used to have Vanessa atalanta for a while too.

    Luckily, my P. maacki survived the night so hopefully it’s ok.

    I usually have problems feeding this species. I’m worried to handle it too much. There are really no followers yet but do you have a specific solution you use?

    Hello,

    I can’t really rear Papilio maackii where I live. I was just keeping them.

    I was going to maybe try to get the host but then this happened.

    I took a picture last night when it was doing fine.

    Now it’s on the ground twitching and hardly moving.

    This happened back in November as well.

    nothing wrong with his abdomen. what you are seeing is the open clusters since it´s a male.

    how do you feed your butterflies? any particular mixture? what is the temperature durring the day (since you only mentioned the temperature at night)

    is it possible that there is direct sunlight shining through the window right onto the netcage? the specimen shown in the picture looks a bit exhausted.

    how old is the dying one ?

  • ANZEIGE

    I haven’t fed this one yet. I only fed it some honey solution in a towel and it fed about 5 seconds at 9 am this morning. During the day it’s about 70 with the pet lamp on it. There is some sun light on it by the window also the lamp but my other butterflies usually like that.

    The specimen is hardly a day old. I don’t know why it’s exhausted. I have 2 others in a chrysalis that will hatch soon. I don’t want them to have the same fate.

    I can´t tell for sure what´s wrong but I would recommend you try something different.

    don´t rear the adult butterfly in high humidity ( normal room humidity is enough) and avoid this lamp except you want to handpair them or stimulate a female for egg laying.

    place the butterfly in direct sunlight for a few minutes to see if it starts flying arround. In my opinion this is very important to get the metabolism started and helps to get rid of the digestive remains from the pupae stage . after this, place it in a dark spot without a lamp or direct sunlight. feed it twice a day.

    however, maackii is a strong flyer and not suitable for beeing kept in such a small cage for a longer time.

    Don’t butterflies need heat to fly and aren’t they native to hot regions?

    My nymphalids usually like the heat lamp. Hand pairing would be great but I just need them to not die right away. This never happens with any other butterflies except swallowtails.

    Would you recommend putting 2 of my 6ft by 4ft cages together?

    I suppose each species is different. I have a 3'x18"x18" cage I have used for Papilio polyxenes, and Papilio

    macheon oregonius, perhaps a dozen at a time.

    I use a full spectrum led light panel- that's 11.5" sq.

    I used hummingbird nectar with electrolytes, and had to unfurl the proboscis with a toothpick, placing into

    the nectar, they would either resist, or sit and drink for 90 seconds or more.

    All room temperature- my room at 70f or better.

    Fed a day after hatching, in the morning and again in the afternoon sometimes.

    Ambient natural light, not direct sunlight.

    All the butterflies would live what I assume were long lives, several weeks. In the wild, perhaps

    they might last longer, avoiding predators of course.

    Bigger is better, but not always possible, perhaps as the weather warms, you can use a larger

    outdoor cage, if you can avoid escapes.

    Humidity- indoors runs 50% give or take a little.

    I'd try something different, if what you're doing isn't working.

    Hi Kevin,

    Thanks for your answer.

    My setup is just like yours.

    In the summer, I did keep them outside. I was told it’s better to keep them in a cooler place. Also, all winter my other butterflies have been living extremely long. Except for the swallowtails.

    What would just make a healthy brand new male keel over and die not even a day after emergence.

    No direct sun.

    Should I try a humidifier?

    You have a mystery Ethan, I don't think it's humidity, as far a being kept in a cage outdoors, the issue becomes

    the perfect location, where the butterflies can find shade and get out of the sun, a small cage, even a large

    reptarium, or net style cage probably would not be big enough.

    I have a contact here in Oregon that raises butterflies on a large scale, very large scale. He uses a big

    portable gazebo, like a screen tent, at least he sent me a picture of one, he probably has more than one.

    You could try other species of Papilio, or take a break from them, and get more experience with other

    butterflies, I don't raise butterflies often, moths are a bit easier, sometimes anyway.

    I have a friend in the UK that raises Papilios, I send him USA livestock sometimes, I'll mention your issue and

    maybe he might respond to your post. He also raises maackii sometimes, I think he uses a big room or

    conservatory/greenhouse.

    Hi Ethan,

    have followed the contributions above. Unfortunately I've got no experiences with butterflies but have visited many Butterfly Parks in SE Asia. You're right, butterflies like / need sunshine and heat and they like to fly around. Your exhausted Papilio is hardly damaged so it was not flying too much and consequently the cage seems to be not too small. One problem might be the feeding with honey solution. Most of the honey offered is not poisonous for human although contaminated with pestizides etc. So, the contamination, if any, might have hurt your Papilio though the honey has been within the acceptable range for human use. Butterflies very like to drink clean water. I observed Papilio sitting on the ground sucking water from a shallow stone or from the sand at the river banks in the tropics. They like contamination with urine (salt)! In Butterfly Parks they accept sucking from rotten bananas and pineapple. They do not need honey solution since they will not find any honey solution in the wild. Honey solution might "glue" the proboscis. You should try with clean water rather.

    Cheers

    Ulrich

    Hello at all,

    as Ulrich already wrote, day-flying butterflies like to suck in damp places and absorb water and the minerals dissolved in it.

    According to my observations with Apatura iris, however, they are also able to extract the minerals from absolutely dry places

    like gravel paths. For this purpose they put a drop of water on the dry stone with the help of their proboscis and suck in the

    water and the minerals now dissolved in it.

    Feeding honey water is absolutely not recommended!!!

    A better alternative is to buy in America hummingbird food solution and give something diluted to the butterflies.

    But please make sure that it is not only a sugar/water mixture, but also contains necessary minerals and electrolytes.

    Kevin

    Thanks. Maybe he will have an answer.

    As far as I’m concerned, Papilio glaucus, troilus, Graphium species, and P. maackii and very distant relatives. (Are they?)

    They all seem to follow the same pattern. Could there be plants that are toxic to just Papilio? I hope your friend has an answer.

    @Ulrich

    Hi.

    I’ll will try using clean water. 30 minutes prior to the “incident” it was eating honey. I used “natural honey” but maybe it does have pesticides. Hummingbird feeder should be safe. Banana is usually my go to food but swallowtails don’t seem to eat that.

    Frank

    Well I guess I’ll take a try at hummingbird food. I guess that should help them long term but just getting them to live one night is a challenge. Is there “symptoms” of a toxic butterfly that would match the Papilio?

    It’s dead now but when it was alive?

    Thank you all for your answers!

  • ANZEIGE

    Good luck! Frank and Ulrich have good suggestions, Bees and ants are insects that eat honey, I think there

    is a moth that eats honey, but butterflies will never find it in nature.

    Make sure any solution you use is not just sugar water.

Jetzt mitmachen!

Sie haben noch kein Benutzerkonto auf unserer Seite? Registrieren Sie sich kostenlos und nehmen Sie an unserer Community teil!